In Georgia injury litigation, few documents carry more pressure than a formal offer of settlement under O.C.G.A. § 9-11-68. Turn one down, and if the verdict comes in too low, you can be ordered to pay the other side’s attorney fees. Defense firms know this, and they use these offers to squeeze plaintiffs into accepting less than their cases are worth.
But the statute cuts both ways. Because it shifts fees away from the ordinary American Rule, Georgia courts hold the party making the offer to strict standards. The Georgia Court of Appeals’ decision in CaseMetrix, LLC v. Sherpa Web Studios, Inc., 353 Ga. App. 768, 839 S.E.2d 256 (2020), is one of the clearest examples of what happens when a defendant gets the drafting wrong.
How Georgia’s Offer of Settlement Statute Works
Section 9-11-68 applies only to tort claims. Either side may serve a written offer to settle. If a defendant’s offer is rejected and the final judgment is less than 75% of the offer, the defendant may recover the reasonable attorney fees and expenses it incurred from the date of rejection. If a plaintiff’s offer is rejected and the judgment exceeds 125% of the offer, the plaintiff may recover fees from the defendant.
To trigger those consequences, the offer has to satisfy a list of statutory requirements. Among other things, it must be in writing, identify the parties, identify generally the claim or claims it is attempting to resolve, and state with particularity any relevant conditions. Those last two requirements decided CaseMetrix.
The Facts
CaseMetrix built searchable databases of settlements and verdicts in motor vehicle and premises liability cases, and it was developing a similar database for workers’ compensation claims. Sherpa Web Studios hosted those databases. According to CaseMetrix, when Sherpa moved the databases to a new hosting service, it failed to properly migrate the workers’ compensation database and failed to keep a backup, and the data was lost.
CaseMetrix sued Sherpa for negligence and for breach of contract, seeking more than $4.1 million.
Before trial, Sherpa served a $30,000 offer of settlement. One paragraph of the offer described it as resolving pending claims arising out of claims sounding in tort. The very next paragraph said the offer was meant to resolve all of CaseMetrix’s claims. And as a condition of payment, the offer required CaseMetrix to file a dismissal with prejudice of all its claims, which would have included the contract claim. CaseMetrix rejected the offer.
At trial, the jury found for CaseMetrix on the negligence claim and awarded $6,269, but awarded nothing on the contract claim. The jury also assigned CaseMetrix 46% of the fault, which reduced its recovery to about $3,385, roughly 11% of the rejected offer and far below the 75% threshold.
Sherpa moved for attorney fees under § 9-11-68. The Fulton County Superior Court acknowledged that the offer’s language was inconsistent but concluded that the tort-only paragraph clarified its scope. It granted fees, cutting the requested amount in half.
The Court of Appeals Reverses
In an opinion by Judge Hodges, joined by Presiding Judge Dillard and Judge Gobeil, the Court of Appeals reversed the fee award outright.
The court started from two settled principles. First, the statute is limited to tort claims. Second, because § 9-11-68 is in derogation of the common law, it must be strictly construed against an award of fees and limited to its plain terms.
Applying those principles, the court held that Sherpa’s offer was internally inconsistent and therefore ambiguous about which claims it covered. The trial court’s reading only worked if a reader ignored the paragraph promising to resolve all claims and ignored the condition requiring dismissal of every claim CaseMetrix had. The court found an “equally plausible reading” under which the offer required CaseMetrix to give up its contract claim too. A court cannot rewrite an offer by choosing the one sentence that saves it.
The court explained that the statute’s purpose is to encourage good-faith settlement of tort claims, and that purpose is defeated when the recipient has to guess at what is being offered. A party deciding whether to accept an offer, with fee exposure hanging over its head, is entitled to know exactly which claims it would be giving up. Relying on its earlier decision in Tiller v. RJJB Associates, 331 Ga. App. 622 (2015), the court held that an offer that fails to clearly identify the claims it resolves and its material conditions does not comply with the statute. Because Sherpa’s offer was invalid, Sherpa was not entitled to fees, and the court did not need to reach CaseMetrix’s other arguments about the fee calculation and the offer’s confidentiality provision.
The court also rejected Sherpa’s reliance on Hillman v. Bord, 347 Ga. App. 651 (2018), which had upheld offers covering both tort and non-tort claims. Hillman was physical precedent only, so it did not bind the panel, and it never considered whether the offer was ambiguous.
Why This Case Matters
CaseMetrix has become a go-to authority in Georgia fee disputes. The Court of Appeals relied on it the following year in Eichenblatt v. Piedmont/Maple, LLC, 358 Ga. App. 234 (2021), to strike down another offer that reached beyond tort claims, and it is regularly cited for the rule that § 9-11-68 must be strictly construed.
For injured people and their lawyers, the lessons are practical.
Read every defense offer closely. A § 9-11-68 offer is not valid simply because it says it is. If the offer is unclear about which claims, which parties, or which conditions are involved, it may not carry any fee consequence at all.
Watch for mixed claims. Many cases involve more than a pure tort claim: a contract claim against a business, an uninsured motorist claim against an insurer, a bad faith claim, or claims against multiple defendants. An offer that sweeps in non-tort claims, or that demands a dismissal or release broader than what it purports to settle, is vulnerable.
Look at the conditions, not just the cover paragraph. In CaseMetrix, the release and dismissal conditions were what exposed the problem. Defense offers often bury the real scope in the fine print: dismissal of the entire action, a general release, indemnity obligations, or confidentiality terms. Those conditions must be stated with particularity and must match the claims the offer says it resolves.
Plaintiffs must draft carefully too. The same strict construction applies when a plaintiff serves an offer to set up a fee recovery against a defendant. A sloppy plaintiff’s offer can be just as unenforceable as Sherpa’s was.
The Bottom Line
Georgia’s offer of settlement statute is a powerful tool, and defendants use it to put pressure on injured people. But the statute rewards precision and punishes ambiguity. Under CaseMetrix, an offer that leaves the recipient guessing about what is being settled is no offer at all, at least for purposes of shifting attorney fees.
If you have been injured and have received a settlement offer, or a defense lawyer is warning that you will owe their fees if you lose, talk to an experienced trial lawyer before you decide. Georgia Florida Trial Lawyers handles catastrophic injury, trucking, traumatic brain injury, and premises liability cases throughout Georgia and Florida.
Received an Offer of Settlement in Georgia?
An offer of settlement under O.C.G.A. § 9-11-68 comes with a response window that can be as short as 30 days, and the choice to accept or reject it can carry real fee consequences. Before that window closes, have a lawyer check whether the offer of settlement clearly identifies the claims, the parties, and the conditions the statute requires. You can read the Court of Appeals’ full opinion in CaseMetrix, LLC v. Sherpa Web Studios, Inc. to see exactly how the court analyzed Sherpa’s offer.
Settlement questions come up in other ways too. A deal can sometimes become binding before anything is signed, as we explain in our post on whether a verbal settlement agreement in Georgia is legally binding. If a defense lawyer has served you with an offer of settlement, or is warning that you could owe their fees, schedule a free consultation or call (407) 718-2128.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and the law can change; consult a licensed attorney about your situation.
