Latest News

When a Teacher Leaves the Room: What Barnett v. Caldwell Means for Georgia Families

When parents send their children to school, they trust that an adult will be watching. But when a child is seriously hurt — or killed — because no one was watching, Georgia law makes it surprisingly hard to hold the individual teacher responsible. The Supreme Court of Georgia’s decision in Barnett v. Caldwell, 302 Ga. 845 (2018), is one of the most important cases on that question, and every family dealing with a school injury should understand it.

What Happened

On October 14, 2008, near the end of the school day at Benjamin E. Mays High School in Atlanta, a teacher stepped out of her classroom. Before leaving, she asked the teacher next door to “listen out” for her class. The two rooms shared an entrance but were divided by a folding wall, so the neighboring teacher could hear the students but could not see them. A hall monitor was nearby, but the teacher did not ask that person to step in.

While she was gone, a student named Antoine Williams and a classmate began horsing around. Antoine fell, and the other student landed on top of him. When the teacher returned roughly half an hour later, Antoine was unconscious. He was taken to the hospital and pronounced dead. The medical examiner found that a dislocated collarbone had torn a major blood vessel.

The record also showed the teacher’s account shifted over time. She first told the principal she had been in the room the whole time, then later gave different reasons for leaving.

The School’s Own Rule

Atlanta Public Schools had a written policy that seemed to speak directly to the situation. The employee handbook said the classroom teacher is solely responsible for supervising students in the classroom, and that students are never to be left in the classroom unsupervised by a certified employee.

Antoine’s parents sued the teacher personally for wrongful death. Their argument was straightforward: the school told its teachers, in writing, never to leave students unsupervised. She did exactly that, and a child died.

The Legal Question: “Ministerial” vs. “Discretionary”

Under the Georgia Constitution, public employees — including public school teachers — have what is called official immunity. That immunity turns on a distinction that drives nearly every school injury case in this state:

Ministerial duties are simple, absolute, and definite. They leave no room for judgment — the employee just has to carry out a specific task. A public employee can be held personally liable for negligently performing a ministerial duty.

Discretionary duties require personal judgment and deliberation. A public employee is immune from liability for discretionary acts unless the family can prove actual malice or an actual intent to cause injury — an extremely high bar.

So the case came down to one question: was the teacher’s duty to supervise her class a ministerial duty created by the handbook, or a discretionary one?

What the Court Decided

The Supreme Court of Georgia ruled for the teacher and held she was immune.

Importantly, the Court did not say that supervising students is always discretionary. It rejected that broad idea and said the answer depends on the specific act and the specific policy involved. A school policy, directive, or statute can create a ministerial duty — but only if it is clear and definite enough that following it requires no judgment.

The problem in Barnett was that the handbook never defined “supervise” or “unsupervised.” And the principal himself acknowledged that teachers could leave the room in some situations, like an emergency or a short absence, and that a teacher who could hear but not see her students might still be “supervising.” Because the policy left teachers to decide whether to leave, how long to be gone, and who would cover, the Court concluded it called for judgment — which made it discretionary. With no evidence of actual malice, immunity applied.

The Court also made a point that matters a great deal for future cases. The lower court had suggested the teacher did “just enough” — by asking a neighbor to listen out — to make her conduct discretionary. The Supreme Court disagreed with that reasoning. In its view, a duty is either ministerial or discretionary by its nature, and an employee cannot change that by doing the job well, poorly, or not at all. Two justices wrote separately to say that statement went further than necessary and should not be read as a firm rule, particularly where an employee does nothing at all.

Why This Case Matters to Families

Barnett is a hard result, and for Antoine’s family it was a devastating one. But it also gives families and their lawyers a roadmap.

The exact wording of school policies matters. A vague rule about “supervision” will usually be treated as discretionary. A rule that tells employees exactly what to do — specific steps, specific checklists, specific required actions — can create a ministerial duty that removes immunity. The Court pointed to an earlier case involving a receptionist who was required to follow particular checkout procedures as an example of a duty definite enough to qualify.

The investigation has to start early. Because so much depends on the precise language of handbooks, protocols, and procedures, those documents need to be gathered quickly — often through Open Records Act requests — before memories fade and policies get revised.

The teacher is not the only question. Claims against school districts themselves raise separate issues of sovereign immunity, and other individuals — administrators, coaches, nurses, and athletic trainers — may be bound by more specific written protocols than a classroom teacher. Every case needs its own analysis.

Deadlines can be short. Claims involving public entities and employees often carry notice requirements and filing deadlines that are less forgiving than in an ordinary injury case.

The Bottom Line

Barnett v. Caldwell confirms that Georgia’s official immunity doctrine is a serious obstacle in school injury cases — but not an automatic bar. Whether a family can hold someone accountable often turns on the fine print: what the written rules actually required, who they applied to, and whether they left any room for judgment.

If your child has been seriously injured at school or during a school activity in Georgia, it is important to speak with an attorney who understands how these immunity rules work and how to build a case around them.

Talk to a Georgia School Injury Lawyer

A school injury case against a teacher, coach, or other school employee is not an ordinary injury claim. The outcome can turn on a single sentence in a handbook, a missed notice deadline, or whether the claim belongs against the employee or the school system. You can read the Supreme Court of Georgia’s full opinion in Barnett v. Caldwell to see how closely the Court examined the written policy. Every school injury claim deserves that same close look at the documents, ideally before policies are revised or records disappear.

When a child does not survive, the family may also have a wrongful death claim under Georgia law. Drew Gilliland personally reviews every school injury case the firm takes on. If your child was hurt at school or during a school activity, schedule a free consultation or call (407) 718-2128.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Share :

Article Categories

All Services

When a Teacher Leaves the Room: What Barnett v. Caldwell Means for Georgia Families

Contact Us

Blank Form (#3)

Get the Justice You Deserve Today

Don’t wait to protect your rights. Our experienced attorneys are ready to guide you through every step of your personal injury case with compassion, dedication, and proven results. Contact us now for a free consultation and take the first step toward the compensation you deserve.

Call Us Today At